Book Review: Goldenhand, by Garth Nix

Title: Goldenhand
Author: Garth Nix
Publisher: Harper Collins
Release Date: October 4, 2016
The Breakfast Octopus’ rating: B-

Blurb:

Goldenhand takes place six months after the events of Abhorsen and follows the novella Nicholas Sayre and the Creature in the Case, which is featured in Across the Wall.

Lirael lost one of her hands in the binding of Orannis, but now she has a new hand, one of gilded steel and Charter Magic. On a dangerous journey, Lirael returns to her childhood home, the Clayr’s Glacier, where she was once a Second Assistant Librarian. There, a young woman from the distant North brings her a message from her long-dead mother, Arielle. It is a warning about the Witch with No Face. But who is the Witch, and what is she planning? Lirael must use her new powers to save the Old Kingdom from this great danger—and it must be forestalled not only in the living world but also in the cold, remorseless river of Death.

Thoughts:

Sabriel and Lirael, the predecessors to Goldenhand, were two of my favorite books when I was growing up.  I loved the juxtaposition of the magic-filled Old Kingdom and the England equivalent called Ancelstierre.  Sabriel and Lirael followed young women as they grew into their power and adulthood while combatting ancient evil. Lirael’s story in particular drew me; the idea of a library as a place of dangerous objects and potential knowledge dovetails nicely into what I think a library should be.

I was therefore disappointed in GoldenhandAlthough I enjoyed following up with my favorite characters, I felt that it was too neatly wrapped up. Characters that should have been dead were revived, which for me ruined their previous departures. And I thought a lot of the moral ambiguity was sucked out of the story; Sabriel dealt with her necromantic urges and the thin line between good acts and evil ones, while Goldenhand characters are all either good or evil, with no moral shading.

I also thought the description suffered: to me, the book read more like someone was giving me a summary of what happened in the book, rather than drawing me into the plot.  That said, I’m always happy to hear what my favorite characters are up to, so I’ll read any following books as well.

Goldenhand is available now from Harper Collins wherever books are sold.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *